Risk Management · QCRA
Quantitative Cost Risk Analysis (QCRA) Consultancy
Quantitative Cost Risk Analysis (QCRA) tests what your project could really cost, rather than what the estimate hopes it will. BHD puts ranges around the risks in your cost plan, models how they combine, and reports the contingency you need at a confidence level you choose.
When is a QCRA worth commissioning?
Most cost plans carry an allowance for risk. The question is whether that allowance bears any relation to the risks actually on the job. A QCRA is worth commissioning when the answer is unclear: at tender, when you are pricing work you have not built before; when a client or funder asks how the contingency was derived; when the estimate has been cut to win work and the risk has not moved; when a project is drifting and the forecast outturn depends on allowances nobody can defend; or when you are carrying a fixed price and the exposure sits with you.
It is also useful before you sign. Understanding the range of outcomes around your price is a commercial advantage in the negotiation, and it tells you which risks to qualify rather than absorb. Where the exposure is genuinely small and well understood, we will say a quantified analysis is more than the job needs.
The cost risk register comes first
A QCRA needs something to quantify. That means a cost risk register: a list of the specific things that could increase or reduce cost, each described clearly enough that someone can attach a range to it. Vague entries such as "market conditions" cannot be modelled, because nobody can say what they would cost if they happened.
We review the register before modelling. Are the risks specific and owned? Are they recorded against the right element of the cost plan? Are optimistic and pessimistic outcomes both represented? Is anything double counted, in the register and again in the estimate? Are opportunities included, not just threats?
How is the cost modelled?
Monte Carlo modelling is a calculation that runs the project many thousands of times. Each run draws a value for every risk from its range, adds the results together, and records a total cost. After thousands of runs you have a distribution of possible outturns rather than one number.
Timing is what separates a useful model from arithmetic. A risk that might land in the first quarter has a different effect on cashflow from the same risk landing near completion. We model when each risk could occur, which cost period it hits and whether it is a one-off or recurring exposure, so the output can feed a forecast rather than sit beside it. That is also how cashflow exposure becomes visible: the periods where the modelled outturn runs above the money you have available, and how wide that gap could get.
How is contingency set, and what is scenario analysis?
The modelled results are read as confidence levels. A P50 figure has a 50 per cent chance of not being exceeded. A P80 figure has an 80 per cent chance. The gap between your base estimate and the figure at your chosen level is the contingency the analysis supports, and setting it this way gives you a figure with a stated basis instead of a judgement dressed up as a percentage.
Scenario analysis tests the decisions in front of you rather than the project as a whole. What happens to the required contingency if a key risk is mitigated? What if the design change goes ahead? What if a supplier is replaced, or a package is brought in-house? Running the model with those changes shows which action actually reduces exposure and by how much, which is the point of quantifying anything.
What does a client actually receive?
- A reviewed cost risk register, with specific, owned risks tied to the cost plan and opportunities included.
- A three-point estimate for each material risk, with the basis for the low, likely and high figures recorded.
- The model itself, with assumptions, timing and correlations documented so it can be reviewed or repeated.
- A results table of outturn at the confidence levels you asked for, including P50 and P80.
- A recommended contingency figure with the reasoning behind it, held separately from the base estimate.
- A cashflow view showing which periods carry the exposure, and how wide the range is.
- A ranked view of the risks that drive the number and the effect of the mitigation under consideration.
- Scenario results for the options you are weighing.
- A short written report in plain English, and a walkthrough with the people who have to act on it.
The analysis is a snapshot in time. It stays credible only if it is refreshed as the estimate, the risks and the programme change, which is how it links back into cost control and forecasting.
Who you will be working with
BHD is led by a Chartered Construction Manager with 25 years across construction, defence and infrastructure. The work is done by the principal, sized for an SME contractor, and kept plain enough to be challenged by your finance director.
Related analysis
Time risk, analysed the same way.
Cost risk and time risk usually travel together. The companion exercise is Quantitative Schedule Risk Analysis (QSRA), which tests how risks could move your completion dates and sets schedule contingency on the same evidential basis. Both sit inside our wider risk management service and feed project controls and contract and commercial management.
Common questions.
How is a QCRA different from adding a percentage to the estimate?
A flat percentage assumes every risk is equally likely and equally large, which is never true. A QCRA tests each risk on its own range and likelihood, then models how they combine. The result reflects the actual shape of your exposure and gives a defensible basis for the allowance.
How much information do you need from us?
A cost plan or estimate at a usable level of detail, a risk register or access to the people who hold the risks, and the programme so timing can be modelled. If any of that is missing, we will tell you what to put in place first rather than model assumptions we cannot test.
Which confidence level should we use?
It is a commercial choice. P50 is the midpoint: half the modelled outcomes come in above it. Contractors carrying fixed prices, or working to a tight cash position, usually need a higher level. We will show you the cost of each level so the decision is explicit.
Who owns the contingency once it is set?
The business does. We recommend a figure with a stated basis; how it is held, released and reported is a management decision. We recommend reviewing it at each forecast so it does not become an allowance that is quietly spent twice.
Can a QCRA be done at tender stage?
Yes, and it is often most valuable there. It shows the range of outcomes around the price you are about to submit and which risks you should qualify or carry. The model can then be carried into delivery and updated, rather than rebuilt.
Cost risk assessment
Start with a cost risk assessment
If your contingency is a percentage nobody can explain, or a funder has asked how your risk allowance was derived, send us the estimate and the risk register. We will review them, tell you what a cost risk assessment would show, and set out what it would take to get there. It is an enquiry, not a commitment, and if your existing allowance already stands up we will tell you that too.
